Publish Your Research Online
Get Recognition - International Audience
Request for an Author Account | Login | Submit Article
|HOME||FAQ||TOP AUTHORS||FORUMS||PUBLISH ARTICLE|
Genetically Modified Crops and the Myths Associated With ThemBY: Maitree Baral | Category: Biotechnology-products | Submitted: 2013-05-19 09:04:09
Article Summary: "The various myths and facts associated with GM crops. A dearth of critics continue to question genetically modified crops impacts socially, environmentally and economically upon today's society. But lack of concrete scientific evidence fails to present a clear picture about the various myths surrounding the various qualities as .."
Genetically modified (GM) crops are considered a marvel in modern science. In the 20 years they have occupied the commercial scenario there has been a dramatic increase in their acceptance among the agricultural masses. Thus there has been an estimate US$98 billion increase in the agricultural produce and protected the environment from being exposed to about 475 million kilograms of pesticides. Thankfully there never has been a dearth of critics who continued to question its impacts socially, environmentally and economically upon today's society. But lack of concrete scientific evidence fails to present a clear picture about the various myths surrounding the various qualities as suicides, super-weeds and stealthy genes associated with GM crops. We now undertake a sequential analysis of the various myths surrounding GM crops.
Suicide in Indian farmers and GM cotton-
It has been alleged by prominent environmental activists that there have been 2.7 lakh deaths among farmers in India since the introduction of genetically modified Bt cotton in early 2000s.
The initial high cost of Bt cotton (nearly 5 times the local hybrid varieties) forced local traders to mix Bt and conventional cotton to be sold at a lower price. This adulteration combined with the lack of knowledge of utilization of crop resulting in financial losses and crop wastage which created a bad impact on the already high debt ridden Indian farmers resulting in suicides, as all edged by various environmentalists.
Contrary to the above accusation there has been slight increase in the suicide rate since the introduction of Bt Cotton and prevalence of various other causative factors in suicide among farmers like lack of rainfall and financial hardships have been identified.
There has been an increase in about 24% in the yield in GM cotton leading to a profit of about 50% as compared to conventional cotton for farmers contrary to popular belief. This strongly substantiates its utility when nearly 90% of cotton grown in India is Genetically Modified. Thus the myth is baseless.
The rise of GM induced super weeds-
Palmer amaranth (Amaranthus palmeri) is a prominent weed growing in cotton fields and outruns it in the quest for soil nutrients, moisture and sunlight thus substantially decreasing the cotton output of the field. US farmers since the late 1990s have been adopting the herbicide glyphosate resistant GM cotton variety. This led to an increase in yield in cotton with a substantial decrease in weeds until the emergence of the glyphosate-resistant strain of Palmer amaranth in 2004 in a county of Georgia which within a span of 7 years it had spread nearly 80 counties. Herbicide resistance continues to be a problem irrespective of development of herbicide-tolerant crops as well. This has been a result of the absence of conventional methods like using a mixture of multiple herbicides and ploughing and tilling of land. Moreover crop resistance which led to substantial decrease in weed species with increase in soil fertility was not adequately practiced with the rise in GM crops.
According to International Survey of Herbicide Resistant Weeds, glyphosate resistant weeds have spread to as many as 18 countries around the globe with major impacts in countries like Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Australia.
Experts acknowledge that compared to conventional crops which are grown at an industrial scale herbicide-resistant GM crops confer less damage to the environment and thus the solution according to them lies in the utilization of sustainable farming mechanisms along with intelligent herbicide mixing to reap maximum benefits. Thus the myth is substantiated.
Spread of transgenic to Mexico's wild crops-
This has garnered mixed results from scientific community across the country. The storm originated when a group of rural farmers wanted to obtain a little extra income by certifying the grain they grew in their mountainous home of Oaxaca, Mexico. On analysis by a prominent microbiological ecologist it was found that that the grains contained a segment of the DNA which was used to increase the expression of transgenes in the glyphosate-tolerant and insect-resistant maize marketed by Monsanto. This was in sharp contrast to the GM crops laws in Mexico. It was thus a result of cross breeding with the planted imported grains from the US b farmers who did not know the real identity of the grains as transgenes. The company was also lambasted for spoiling grain at its place of origin. Subsequently different group of researches obtained contrasting results with some proving the theory otherwise. Thus this remains a contradictory theory with no answer to the myth as of now.
GM crops are alleged to solve the hunger crisis of the developed and the developing countries but according to experts on both sides of the arguments, the answer lies somewhere in between the two extremes.
About Author / Additional Info:
Maitree Baral holds Masters in Bioinformatics and shows profound interest in shraing and discussing various biological aspects.
Comments on this article: (0 comments so far)
• Ribozymes: Molecular Scissors For Genetic Manipulations
• Biotechnology in Leather Production
• Types Of Gene Therapy - Advantages And Disadvantages of Gene Therapy
• Natural Growth Hormone: IAA (Indole-3-Acetic Acid)
Latest Articles in "Biotechnology-products" category:
• How Biotechnology Helps Create Biofuels
• Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay (ELISA): Procedure, Applications, Types
• Biotechnology in the Manufacturing of Detergents
• Marine Biotechnology and its Applications in Making Drugs
• Agarose Gel DNA Electrophoresis - Applications, Advantages and Disadvantages
• Biochemistry Analyzers: Uses and Types
• Biomarkers and Diagnosis of Diseases
• Trends in Biotech Engineered Vaccines
• Biotechnology and Cosmetics
• Technique of Gene Gun
• Biotechnology in the Manufacture of Paper
• Importance of Biofuels or Biodiesels and How they are produced.
• Mussel Biopolymers: A Cloning Approach
• Anthrax Detection Device and Toxic Mold Detection Device
• Recombinant DNA Technology and the Pharmaceutical Industry
• Process of Electroporation: Definition and Applications
• Production of Recombinant Human Growth Hormone Somatotropin
• Somatic Cell Fusion- A Biotechnology Technique
• Recombinant Protein Expression System
Important Disclaimer: All articles on this website are for general information only and is not a professional or experts advice. We do not own any responsibility for correctness or authenticity of the information presented in this article, or any loss or injury resulting from it. We do not endorse these articles, we are neither affiliated with the authors of these articles nor responsible for their content. Please see our disclaimer section for complete terms.
Copyright © 2010 biotecharticles.com - Do not copy articles from this website.
ARTICLE CATEGORIES :
| Disclaimer/Privacy/TOS | Submission Guidelines | Contact Us